3M Absolute Waterproof is the best tape period, other than the kind of rubbery smell. It's stretchy, very tacky but leaves zero residue, sticks enough to itself without losing grip much over time, and removes easily when you're ready. Breathable like transpore, but much more stretchy, so it works both hard and soft.
Also FYI for those who wouldn't tell the world that foreskin retraction is one of your "hobbies", I feel I should make a few points:
First, your ISP knows whichever websites you are going to unless you are using some kind of proxy, anonymization software/service, or onion routing. Unless you are using internet software designed for privacy and anonymity, google and facebook and yahoo etc know where you are browsing, and they put together a profile on you for "marketing and 'personalization' purposes". And yeah, they will give that data to a government upon request. It's not paranoia, it's actually reality. If you would like to know more, look up the "Utah Data Center", a horrible waste of $2 Billion American taxpayer money.
Second, you can protect yourself by using software designed for anonymity, security, and privacy. Much of this software is free, even at the operating system level. Look up Whonix, TOR, and Tails. More user friendly than you'd think. Though the US govt has violated it's own 4th amendment by unlawful surveillance without a warrant, with these tools, you CAN protect your privacy and anonymity. If you have a career in the public light such as a teacher, coach, clergy, politician, etc, and don't think it'd be a good idea to inform the whole world say, that you enjoy periodically wearing your foreskin retracted, it's a no-brainer to use these tools.
Not intending to be inflammatory about this stuff guys, but I feel it's a crime to keep this info to myself.