Will you instruct your sons to permanently retract?

[hung.part.timer]

I don't have a son myself, but I'm very interested in what you fathers and fathers-to-be have chosen to teach your sons.

I assume none of us will circumcise our sons as we don't want to impose that decision upon an autonomous individual. But I'm wondering if instructing our sons - even in their teens - to pull back 24/7 is coercing a decision upon them as well. Yes, this is obviously not even close to the same impact or brutality of non-consenting circumcision.

Thinking about the prominence of circ-ing in the states, I can't help but imagine if 19th century American Victorians had instituted retraction instead of RIC then we'd all just have a convo around 13 and them make a choice.

What do you think? How will you choose to transmit this practice to the next generation?

[baremountainman]

I have 2 sons in their 20s and they are not circumcised. My own retractions have been brief until recently when I decided to permanently retract. We never had the retraction conversation. I've discussed hygiene and am available for advice on treating an infection but that hasn't come up either. I guess if I was approached about a foreskin issue, I would include retraction as an option. The practice was not passed down to me. I sort of began experimenting to see how the other half lives being that we live among the cut and are a minority in America.

[stephan29]

As a young boy I was told to push my foreskin behind and leave it behind. The foreskin was too tight back then and it should probably be stretched additionally. So I would at least show/explain to my sons (I don't have any) that it's possible and if they want to do it, they can/should do it, but only if they want to.

[hung.part.timer]

As a young boy I was told to push my foreskin behind and leave it behind. The foreskin was too tight back then and it should probably be stretched additionally. So I would at least show/explain to my sons (I don't have any) that it's possible and if they want to do it, they can/should do it, but only if they want to.

May I ask where you grew up? Did your father or brothers also keep their foreskin retracted?

[stephan29]

May I ask where you grew up? Did your father or brothers also keep their foreskin retracted?

sorry haven't answered yet. Come from Germany. and my father didn't wear the foreskin behind.

[Tfloyd]

I will tell my son about retraction. I wish I would've known about it years before I did. My father was cut so didn't have any information to give

[Jagtstein]

I will not recommend retracting the foreskin to my sons. Because I know that doing so will make the glans less sensitive. I will recommend masturbation with the foreskin to my sons. I will also recommend removing the frenulum as this will allow the foreskin to slide more freely over the glans. You should start masturbating as early as possible. Because that's very healthy.

[adan]

we have a japanese member in the forum, he sayd there that instruction, and the practice is common, so, it can be done.
My father taught this for me and my brothers, no one got used to, even trying.
I don't do a bad judgment about who circ the children, they want the best for him( like who don't circ want the best to) kid pain a lot in that age, the body not yet fully formed, this hurt. Is the age when the pain matter less, because everything hurt. there are a lot of reasons to don't circ (others to do), pity is the worst.